cannon-chambers-logo
Menu

BRANDBROS LIMITED V HMRC [2021]

This decision addresses the effect for SDLT purposes of the grant of a commercial lease over the garage of a residential property by the purchaser on the day of completion and whether that had the effect of causing the property purchased to be treated as mixed-use.

The FTT held in favour of HMRC and decided that the grant of the lease was a separate transaction and did not affect the treatment of the prior purchase of the dwelling earlier in the day as residential despite the reference in section 119 FA 2003 to the date and not the time of completion.

The FTT also said obiter that the grant of the lease (as distinct from the actual use which occurred later) did not alter the use of the garage for SDLT purposes.

This decision leaves open the question of what type of commercial use occurring in the grounds of a residential property will be sufficient to cause the property purchased to be considered mixed-use. Patrick Cannon pressed the Upper Tribunal during the Hyman appeal to answer this question but the judges did not respond to this invitation and so the matter remains to be decided.

Read the full decision here.

Click here to view our latest notable cases.

You might also be interested in...

L-L-O CONTRACTING LIMITED AND OTHERS V HMRC [2025] UKUT 00127 (TCC)

This was the hearing before the Upper Tribunal of the appellants' claims for overpayment relief from SDLT under paragraph 34 Schedule 10 FA 2003 in circumstances where the appellants had failed to claim Multiple Dwellings Relief ("MDR") in their return or in an amendment to their return, within 12 months...

CHARLIE JOHNSON V HMRC TC/2024/00254

This was a successful appeal by the taxpayer about whether multiple dwellings relief ("MDR") from SDLT applied to his purchase of a residential property with a self-contained annex. In a carefully structured and considered decision the FTT reviewed the evidence thoroughly and held that HMRC's objections concerning the interconnecting doors and shared...
Contact Us